Finn has eaten SO many cat toys. He steals them whenever he can and he's super sneaky about it, too.
A couple weeks ago, when I was asleep in bed, he tried to steal some out of the cat teepee, got his head stuck, and leapt straight up onto the bed, legs scrambling, teepee still on his head, barking furiously. I had scratches all over my body, some of which are just finally healing now!
He especially loves the toys with little faces, like this mouse. The kitties have a hedgehog toy that he always finds. You can tell it's in his mouth because he comes into the room with mouth firmly closed, eyes shifting from side to side like Jon Lovitz. When I pry his mouth open, the hedgehog is always sitting on his tongue, damp but unscathed, looking pitifully up at me.